Splendid colour tips for quilters: Colour coordination and layout

For us quilters, colour coordination is often the most difficult part of a project. How do I choose fabrics for my quilt so that they will look great together? How do I design the colours for my blocks? How do I lay out the different coloured blocks into a pleasing design?

In this post, I will share my thoughts on colour coordination and layout – what to understand about oneself, what to watch out for, and how to be successful in colour coordination.

First, how do you plan your quilt

Before considering colour coordination, it is helpful to understand one’s preferred way to approach a quilt project. I’ve identified four basic approaches for planning. It is likely that one way to plan comes most naturally to you. Which is it? Do you: 
  1. Plan the whole quilt first, colours, layout, everything.
  2. Plan my quilt block including its colours, then make enough of them – all similar.
  3. Plan a few optional colours for my quilt block(s) and make enough of them. Then take those blocks and organise them into a pleasing layout.
  4. Choose a block design and make enough of them, in whatever colours that please me. Then take the blocks and organise them into a pleasing layout. This layout may also be random.
Whichever type of quilt planner you may be, recognise your preference. It affects the way you can approach colour coordination.

What to watch out for when thinking about colour coordination

Colour gets the credit, value does the work

If a quilt doesn’t come out as lovely as one has hoped, it is easy to blame it on the colour choices. However, surprisingly often the colours aren’t wrong; instead, the issue is usually with value contrast. There may be too little or too much value contrast.

When coordinating colours in quilting, it is usually not enough to see that the colours look nice together. Whenever you have a quilt block with a definite design, you need that design to stand out, and value contrast is the way to achieve it. Colour contrast is not enough, not in quilting.

When I was making the first Blue North Strong and Free block in 2020, I chose to use a colourful fabric whose pattern looked clear and busy enough to stand out next to the solid blacks. I was wrong:
As you can see from the image above, the block pattern does not stand out properly. This block did not become part of the finished quilt.

(There is another mistake in the block, but that would have been possible to fix.)

Beware of rules of thumb

It is also easy to fall into a trap of colour “rules” such as “brown and blue do not go together,” or “yellow is a difficult colour”. You should recognise the colours and colour combinations that you find most pleasing. You may find that a certain brown together with a certain blue will feel right to you, no matter the “rule”.

In addition, you should recognise which colours you don’t like, either on their own of in combination with a certain other colour. You don’t have to use colours (or patterns) that you don’t like. If you start out with a fabric pull that looks dull and uninspiring, take a time out and think again.

Ways to be successful in colour coordination and layout

Let your preferences guide your colour choices, coordination and layout.

Your available colour choices do not being at your stash: they begin when you shop your fabrics. If you know what you like and prefer to use, be sure to fill your stash with those colours and hues – and remember to get light and dark fabrics in addition to the most common medium value ones.

If your stash consists of fabrics in subdued or muted colours, you won’t be able to sew a bright-coloured quilt. And if you want to sew a sweet pastel coloured quilt, you cannot achieve it from a brownish fabric pull such as this one:
Be very alert and sensitive when browsing for new fabric. If you happen to come across a startlingly attractive fabric, consider adding it to your stash. When a fabric makes an impression at first sight, it will be likely to inspire you at home, too. And inspiring fabric is the most fun to work with!
Sadly, some fabrics lose their attractiveness while they are in storage. If a fabric no longer inspires you and you don’t feel it could ever make a comeback, find a way to honourably remove it from your stash.

If you are of Type 2 (the second one on the list that I gave in the beginning) when planning your quilts, my tip to you is to make a test block first. Then, check that your block has enough value contrast. Because our eyes are not great at sensing differences in value between different colours, it is a good idea to take a picture of the test block, adjust its colouring to monochrome and check the value in that black-and-white picture.

If you are of Type 4 quilt planner (the fourth one on the list), you work like me: sew enough blocks, then organise them into a pleasing layout. In that layout phase, you can follow these five steps:

1.

Sort your quilt blocks into piles of light and dark value, possibly also light medium and dark medium values.

2.

Starting from the lightest blocks, lay them out on the uppermost rows. Then, continue with light mediums, dark mediums, finishing with the darkest blocks on the lowermost rows.
Optionally, you could layout your lightest blocks into the upper middle, then continue with darker blocks out of the middle and centre, like in this quilt surface:

3.

Examine how the layout looks. Does it please your eyes enough? It is ok to accept a design that comes about like this, at semi random. Likewise it is ok if you want to tweak your first design. You decide what is best.

4.

If something is bothering you, first identify the blocks that seem to jump out. Reconsider their placement: perhaps they are too close to each other? Or, if they are of the same colour, perhaps you think they should be closer to each other, and have a few more similarly-coloured blocks close by.

You can also take a picture of your first layout and first look at it on the small screen (of your phone, most likely). Bothersome spots in the layout are often easier to pinpoint from this small image.

Then, you can also adjust that image to be monochrome and then look at how your values flow. You will be able to see more clearly if the flow looks wrong or not smooth enough.

Sometimes an image will make you spot a serious flaw in your design. You are lucky if you catch that flaw in the layout phase, but it won’t be too late to correct a quilt top, either. This happened to me when I was making the Tasapeli / It’s a Tie quilt. I had placed the darkest X block too carelessly, and in the photo, it was obviously in the wrong place:
The progression from dark to light is smooth and no block stands out in a disturbing way on the finished It’s a Tie quilt:

5.

After the layout and the necessary tweaks, you can just sew the quilt blocks together into a surface. It is worth remembering that you have the permission to achieve less than an absolutely perfect layout! Good enough is enough.

The easiest way to choose coordinating fabrics for your quilt?

If you find it impossible to decide on the coordinating colours for your next quilt, don’t even try! The easiest way to solve the problem is to use all the colours. Just make sure that your colourful surface has rhythm or value contrast – or better yet, both. I’ve listed all of seven ways to do that in my blog post Splendid colour tips for quilters: All the colours in one quilt.

Final thoughts on colour coordination

If you find yourself worrying about matching or coordinating colours, take care of value contrast instead! It is the one thing most likely to help you when planning the colours, fabrics or layout for your quilt.

Make sure that your quilt has value contrast where it matters:
  • In the blocks, if you want the block design to be clear
  • Between the blocks and sashings or borders, if your quilt has those
  • In your quilt in general – unless you seek to achieve that look. A quilt sewn entirely of pieces or blocks with uniform value will offer no focus points for the eye.
When I was making my first quilts, I did not know how important value contrast is. Be smarter than I was!

Earlier posts in the splendid colour tips series

In case you have missed some of my colour tips, here is a comprehensive list: I’ll be discussing other colour topics soon, sharing tips and stories from my own quilts. If you want to be sure to get all my colour tips – and possibly other fun updates as well – you can subscribe to my biweekly newsletter.

(When subscribing, remember to take the second step: you will get an email asking you to confirm. My emailing system can only send you the newsletters if you have clicked on the button in that email.)

Comments

Most popular this week

Overnight quilted zipper bag and the colour of November

Get inspired by holiday quilting projects I’ve made over the years: 11 ideas

Finished: Terrain quilted zipper bag